Can Richard Posner do arithmetic?

Slate has published a letter from Richard Posner criticising Scalia’s dissent on the Arizona immigration case. Posner is typically shallow in blathering uncritically about how immigration helps everyone.

Things get more interesting when Posner takes aim at Scalia’s statement that Arizona “bears the brunt of the country’s illegal immigration problem.” Posner rests his argument with what seems to be a simple error in arithmetic. He notes that “there are 10 million to 11 million illegal immigrants” in the country and then tells us that

As of last year there were estimated to be 360,000 illegal immigrants in Arizona, which is less than 6 percent of the Arizona population—below the estimated average illegal immigrant population of the United States.

Now, I make six percent of the current US population to be some 18.8 million, which is far more than 10-11 million. It follows that percentage of the population of Arizona that is illegal is higher in Arizona than it is in the rest of the country.

Now, Posner’s writing is unclear. One could also read his sentence as saying that 360,000 is less than the average number of illegals in a state, i.e. than 10-11 million divided by 50 ~= 200,000. This is also false: 360,000 is comfortably more than 200,000.

How did Posner not see this? How did his editors not see this? How stupid can our establishment overlords get?


About Pechorin

A Hero of Our Time
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Can Richard Posner do arithmetic?

  1. Columnist says:

    They can only do math when it suits them.

  2. And Balls says:

    He wants a citation.

    “But the suggestion that illegal immigrants in Arizona are invading Americans’ property, straining their social services, and even placing their lives in jeopardy is sufficiently inflammatory to call for a citation to some reputable source of such hyperbole. Justice Scalia cites nothing to support it.”

    Step 1: Open your eyes and look around you.
    Step 2: Talk to an honest social services or hospital worker.
    Step 3: Read anything besides the mainstream news and wash dc policiticians’ press releases.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s